Canada
Canadian total-loss settlements are governed by Actual Cash Value (ACV) — the replacement cost of a comparable vehicle, not book or trade-in value. Every province has a statutory appraisal/arbitration mechanism you can invoke when you and the insurer cannot agree.
Provincial Insurance Acts · federal Insurance Companies Act
Your key rights
Actual Cash Value standard
Insurers must pay the actual cash value of the vehicle, less any deductible. ACV is the replacement cost for a comparable vehicle — not Black Book or trade-in.
Right to appraisal / arbitration
If you disagree with the insurer's valuation, you can request an independent appraisal. Each side appoints an appraiser; if they disagree, an umpire issues a binding decision.
Provincial variations
Ontario: written appraisal request triggers a formal process. Alberta: insurer must provide Section 519 dispute provisions within 10 days. Quebec: Endorsement No. 43 governs total-loss compensation. BC: ICBC has its own process with escalation to the Civil Resolution Tribunal.
Right to use market evidence
Comparable adverts from AutoTrader.ca, Kijiji and dealer inventories are routinely used to challenge a low offer.
GIO and provincial regulators
The General Insurance OmbudService (GIO) handles unresolved P&C complaints federally; provincial regulators (e.g. FSRA in Ontario) supervise market conduct.
Varies by province (typically 1–2 years from the date of loss)
Common range is 1 year (e.g. Quebec for many claims) to 2 years (Ontario, Alberta). Always confirm the specific limitation in your province.
Independent, free dispute resolution for federally regulated P&C insurers. Recommendations are highly persuasive.
Think you've been underpaid?
Get a free, no-obligation analysis of your settlement. We'll tell you within days whether there's a real case to push back.
Get my free analysisOther markets we cover
Browse the brief for any country in our footprint.