Canada
Canadian total-loss settlements are governed by Actual Cash Value (ACV) — the replacement cost of a comparable vehicle, not book or trade-in value. Every province has a statutory appraisal/arbitration mechanism you can invoke when you and the insurer cannot agree.
Your key rights
Actual Cash Value standard
Insurers must pay the actual cash value of the vehicle, less any deductible. ACV is the replacement cost for a comparable vehicle — not Black Book or trade-in.
Right to appraisal / arbitration
If you disagree with the insurer's valuation, you can request an independent appraisal. Each side appoints an appraiser; if they disagree, an umpire issues a binding decision.
Provincial variations
Ontario: written appraisal request triggers a formal process. Alberta: insurer must provide Section 519 dispute provisions within 10 days. Quebec: Endorsement No. 43 governs total-loss compensation. BC: ICBC has its own process with escalation to the Civil Resolution Tribunal.
Right to use market evidence
Comparable adverts from AutoTrader.ca, Kijiji and dealer inventories are routinely used to challenge a low offer.
GIO and provincial regulators
The General Insurance OmbudService (GIO) handles unresolved P&C complaints federally; provincial regulators (e.g. FSRA in Ontario) supervise market conduct.
Independent, free dispute resolution for federally regulated P&C insurers. Recommendations are highly persuasive.
Provincial Insurance Acts · federal Insurance Companies Act
Varies by province (typically 1–2 years from the date of loss)
Common range is 1 year (e.g. Quebec for many claims) to 2 years (Ontario, Alberta). Always confirm the specific limitation in your province.
Valofair is coming to your market
Be the first to know when Valofair launches. Join the waitlist and we'll reach out as soon as we're ready to take claims in your country.
Join the waitlist for CanadaOther markets we cover
Browse the brief for any country in our footprint.